AI

Another U.S. appellate court goes against Kalshi, building the industry's legal headwinds

Times News policy-spillover note (2026-11-18): Recent weeks have been pretty brutal for Kalshi on the legal front, with losses piling up across the map. States notched two more wins over the prediction… Primary source: original at CoinDesk (coindesk.com).

· CoinDesk

Recent weeks have been pretty brutal for Kalshi on the legal front, with losses piling up across the map. States notched two more wins over the prediction market on sports event contracts on Tuesday:

  • The Tenth Circuit denied an emergency motion from Kalshi asking for an injunction to prevent the state of Utah from taking action against it:

  • Kalshi also lost a bid for a preliminary injunction in Iowa:

I know the Supreme Court could ultimately be what matters most if it takes one of these cases. But still, the scoreboard has been decidedly bad for Kalshi/prediction markets this summer.

When the Third Circuit ruled for Kalshi in the spring in the case against New Jersey, it seemed plausible that Kalshi might be in pretty good shape in other federal appellate courts. That’s not how things turned out.

Kalshi recently lost its preliminary-injunction appeal in the Ninth Circuit against Nevada on sports event contracts. The Sixth and Tenth circuits have denied injunctions pending appeal, while single judges in the Second Circuit have declined temporary relief as the full motions await panel consideration.

We are now confronted with the possibility of a significantly reduced addressable market for sports event contracts if adverse appellate outcomes continue, followed by more state actions.

The four circuits where Kalshi faces headwinds represent 22 states and more than 40% of the population of the country. If more states in all of these circuits actively try to stop Kalshi from offering sports event contracts, that’s starting to become meaningful to Kalshi not just in volume and revenue, but also legal exposure as states try to penalize the prediction market.

Most notable is, of course, California, which is in the Ninth Circuit. California has no legal sports betting and is generally assumed to be a major driver of retail sports volume at Kalshi (and other prediction markets).

California hasn’t sent a cease-and-desist letter to Kalshi on sports event contracts (that we know of). But Attorney General Rob Bonta has joined dozens of other AGs in decrying prediction markets.

From a press release in June about signing onto an amicus brief against Kalshi:

“This filing is representative of our bipartisan commitment to protecting state regulatory authority over illegal, unregulated gambling operations,” said Attorney General Bonta. “Prediction markets cannot use federal loopholes to bypass state consumer protection, sports gaming, and gambling laws. By joining this brief, we are standing firmly with Ohio and our state partners to ensure that federal commodities laws are not weaponized to evade state laws, fuel gambling addiction, and undermine state revenue.”

Many of the other states in these circuits also signed onto efforts against Kalshi or have already tried to take action.

The bottom line is this: Not that long ago Kalshi was offering sports event contracts nationwide. It now faces an uncertain world where it may not be able to serve sports events in a growing number of states beyond those where it has already been forced to pull back, like Nevada, Michigan, and Washington.

At some point, that loss of addressable market for sports — which drives the vast majority of volume and revenue for Kalshi — could start to hurt.

The Event Horizon briefing

A quick look at what matters most in prediction markets.

📍 The Big Story

Beginning Sept. 8, Robinhood will begin routing a selection of football event contracts to Crypto.com’s prediction markets platform through its CFTC-regulated exchange and clearinghouse

Through the first 8 months of the year, prediction markets at Robinhood are seeing record revenues and volumes. In Q2 alone, there were 13.6 billion event contracts traded on Robinhood, and during the World Cup alone more than 5 billion contracts traded. In June, we also started routing contracts to Rothera, a CFTC-licensed exchange and clearinghouse independently managed through Robinhood’s joint venture with Susquehanna International Group, to bring even greater diversity to our marketplace.

Today, we’re building on that momentum as we team up with Crypto.com to begin routing a selection of event contracts to its CFTC-regulated exchange and clearinghouse in time for the start of the Pro Football season. The CFTC-regulated exchange and clearinghouse does business in the Crypto.com App under the brand Crypto.com | Derivatives North America (CDNA) and also a separate trader-focused App under the brand OG.com. We’ll start routing a selection of football contracts to OG.com beginning on Sept. 8.

As part of the deal, Robinhood Markets will hold equity stakes in Crypto.com and OG.com following the latter’s spin-off as an independent trading platform. The equity will be priced in line with the recent investment of Citadel Securities into Crypto.com Group at a $20 billion valuation.

“Routing event contracts to multiple venues helps create a stronger, more diverse and resilient marketplace,” said JB Mackenzie, VP and GM of Futures and Prediction Markets at Robinhood. “With football back and midterms fast approaching, we’re thrilled to team up with Crypto.com and OG.com for what is sure to be an exciting fall for prediction markets on Robinhood.”

“This is the beginning of a strategic partnership between both companies,” said Kris Marszalek, Founder and CEO of Crypto.com and OG.com. “We’re looking forward to making OG.com the most liquid venue globally for innovative derivative instruments, starting with prediction markets and quickly expanding into futures and perpetuals.”

While event contracts on Robinhood will still also be routed to Kalshi, ForecastEX, and Rothera, the deal with Crypto.com and OG.com comes just in time to help bolster our football prediction markets hub. …

In addition to routing a selection of contracts to OG.com, both the Pro and College Football trading experiences are getting a new look. The experience features better live data along with a dedicated trading hub that allows customers to easily filter contracts by week, team, conference, and more. Player stats and team standing data will be coming later this fall. …

This season, customers will also have access to a wider variety of contracts, including contracts on game outcomes, player contracts, custom combos, and more. College and Pro Football contracts will be routed to a combination of OG.com, Kalshi, and Rothera based on a number of factors, including what’s available at each exchange. …

Since launching roughly two years ago, customers have traded over 45 billion contracts on Robinhood, including more than 30 billion this year through the end of August. As Robinhood CEO Vlad Tenev said earlier this year, “prediction markets have become the fastest growing business in our history...I think we’re just at the beginning of a Prediction Markets supercycle...”

  • OG.com has a standalone valuation of $5 billion, per Crypto.com, which is obviously an eye-popping number. Kalshi is valued at $22 billion — more than four times that figure — and has a much larger established prediction-market business.

  • Robinhood at one point was very dependent on Kalshi markets; now with Rothera and this new relationship, it’s far less dependent. If Robinhood views itself as a serious competitor to Kalshi in prediction markets, it would certainly want to continue to wean itself off of extensive use of Kalshi.

  • At one point not that long ago, Robinhood leadership intimated it was moving to a world where it would route as much volume through Rothera as possible. Has that plan changed?

🔭 What To Watch For

After a market about whether NFL players would compete in Week 1 disappeared abruptly, it returned on Tuesday:

  • Kalshi put up markets, including the one above, in August.

  • Polymarket self-certified markets related to injuries, then withdrew then after reportedly consulting with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission.

  • Kalshi took down the above market; Sportico reported that it was at the behest of the CFTC.

  • The NFL sent a letter to Kalshi and others where it termed markets related to injuries “objectionable.”

What’s next? Who knows! I guess we’ll wait to see if there are similar markets for Week 2.

🔥 Hot Market

The season’s opening game between the New England Patriots and Seattle Seahawks has already attracted $5 million in volume at Kalshi:

📝 New Markets

New self-certifications listed with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission:

  • Kalshi self-certified perpetuals for gold and silver:

  • Rothera (Robinhood affiliated) and hockey:

💬 Quote Of The Day

“This is just a very natural market structure that institutions want to trade against the retail flow.”

—Crypto.com Chief Executive Kris Marszalek to the WSJ in its story about Robinhood.

📊 Volume Tracking For Monday, Sept. 7

Cash still has a place in a digital world. Besides being preferred by 63% of gaming app users, cash provides increased security and compliance for operators. With PayNearMe, you can offer a seamless, guaranteed cash-at-retail solution alongside all the popular digital payment methods like Cash App, Apple Pay, Google Pay and more—all from a single integration.

News roundup

Everything else important that happened in or was written about prediction markets:

🚨 Important stuff

  • Polymarket drops commercial with LeBron James: Featuring Emily Ratajkowski, Alexandra Daddario, Olivia Ponton, Spike Lee, Stable Ronaldo, Richard Sherman, Derek Jeter, Reggie Bush, Rajon Rondo, Eli Manning, Sue Bird, John Leguizamo, Craig Robinson, & Bob Stoops:

    • 🔍 The reaction on Twitter again seemed decidedly negative for the celebrities who shared the commercial. Still, it’s clearly designed to help Polymarket gain mainstream acceptance and acquire customers and will probably succeed.

    • ⚡ Polymarket also rose to No. 1 for free finance apps in the App Store on Tuesday — surpassing Kalshi — something that was being celebrated in the Twitter streets. That’s certainly noteworthy, but Kalshi has been No. 1 for finance apps much of the summer and has acquired millions of customers. Polymarket has a lot of ground to make up. If it’s not ahead of Kalshi for large parts of the fall, there’s no way it is catching up this year.

  • BETR LAUNCHES "BETR 2.0" SUPER APP WITH PREDICTION MARKETS AND NEW FLAGSHIP CAMPAIGN FEATURING JEREMY PIVEN, ADRIAN GRENIER, JAKE PAUL, LONZO BALL AND GELO BALL (press release): Jeremy Piven and Adrian Grenier are back together, this time entering the world of Betr. The Entourage stars reunite on screen in a new flagship campaign alongside Jake Paul, Lonzo Ball, and Gelo Ball to introduce Betr 2.0, marking the next evolution of the real-money gaming company founded by Joey Levy and Paul as it builds towards becoming a mainstream real-money gaming super app in the United States.

    • At the center of Betr 2.0 is the launch of prediction markets over a phased rollout in beta to eligible users in select states, with a full release planned for later this football season through Betr’s integration with Polymarket. The launch makes Betr the first consumer app to launch an integration with Polymarket and brings another major product into the Betr ecosystem, with Rips and additional products still to come.

      The new campaign spot, titled SOMETHING BETR, can be viewed HERE.

      The campaign showcases how dramatically Betr has expanded since its launch, bringing together sports, gaming, entertainment and culture while highlighting the growing number of ways consumers can play across the platform. …

    • Through its integration with Polymarket, Betr users will initially be able to access prediction markets covering sports, with additional real-world event markets expected over time.

    • “Betr today is a fundamentally different company than the one we launched, and Predictions going live is an important milestone that allows us to introduce Betr 2.0 and the Super App we’ve been building towards,” said Joey Levy, Founder and CEO of Betr. “Prediction markets are a natural and important extension of that strategy. Nobody knows exactly how the regulatory environment will play out, so having several products regulated differently within one unified experience gives us a differentiated position in the market. We are now the first consumer app to launch Polymarket markets, and we expect to be their largest consumer partner for some time. We have also launched four new products in just 13 months, demonstrating our best-in-class product velocity and unique ability to execute upon an ambitious super app strategy. We plan on launching Rips soon and expect to have at least seven products live within the Betr super app by this time next year, all while rapidly improving and expanding our existing products.”

  • 2026’s elections could test how heavy trading on prediction markets affects races and results (Associated Press): “Their concerns are broad, but many revolve around the fear that pervasive financial incentives will further damage confidence in elections and democracy if Americans think they are influencing the outcome.”

    • “This is a troubling trend that election administrators across the nation must deal with,” said Jared DeMarinis, the administrator for the Maryland State Board of Elections.

⚖️ Legal and regulatory news

  • Robinhood Agrees To Pause Sports Contracts In Michigan (Legal Sports Report): “Robinhood will stop offering new sports-related event contracts to Michigan customers by the end of Wednesday under a court-approved agreement with state officials, extending the practical reach of Michigan’s prediction market crackdown beyond Kalshi.”

  • Underdog Sues Five States Over Sports Event Contracts Just Days After Giving up DFS Licenses in Seven (Sports Betting Dime): “Underdog today filed lawsuits in Ohio, Massachusetts, Wisconsin, New Mexico, and Washington, seeking a permanent injunction against state gambling laws to prohibit their enforcement over its prediction market products, namely sports event contracts.”

  • Illinois Lawmaker Proposes Repeal of Prediction Market Tax (Covers): “Republican Rep. Travis Weaver filed H.B. 5811 on Sept. 2, with the legislation proposing to axe Illinois’ tax on “exchange wagers.” The proposed legislation is still a long way from becoming law, but, if passed, it would remove any references to the prediction market tax from the Illinois Sports Wagering Act. That tax was only signed into law by Gov. JB Pritzker in June and came into effect at the start of July.”

  • New Mexico tribe and pueblos wrap up case that Kalshi sports betting hurts their sovereignty (Source New Mexico): “Three New Mexico pueblos and one tribe on Friday wrapped up their closing arguments that a federal judge should step in to prohibit the online prediction market Kalshi from enabling what the plaintiffs allege amounts to illegal sports gambling on sovereign tribal land.”

📣 Industry news

  • New product lines on Kalshi growing fast (Kalshi blog): “As liquidity concentrates on Kalshi, every new market becomes easier to launch and faster to scale. In almost half the time as crypto markets, Kalshi has scaled its commodities prediction markets to $400M in trading volume. This is more than 4x crypto markets at the same point in their lifecycle.”

  • DraftKings Extends Agreement with IC360 to Enhance Integrity Monitoring and Combat Athlete Harassment Across Sportsbook and Prediction Market Platforms (press release): Integrity Compliance 360, Inc. (IC360), the global technology and advisory leader for integrity and regulatory solutions in sports, sports betting, iGaming, and prediction markets, today announced an agreement with DraftKings Inc. (Nasdaq: DKNG), the digital sports and gaming company. Under the agreement, DraftKings will deploy IC360’s full, industry-leading suite of integrity and compliance technology across both its sportsbook and predictions platform.

    • The agreement marks the first ever single-operator integration in IC360’s ProhiBet and ProhiTrade secure network, uniting four of the company’s flagship technologies under one roof: Integrity Monitoring, ProhiBet, ProhiTrade, and ProhiBet Bad Actors. Together, these solutions give DraftKings a single, unified integrity architecture spanning traditional sports wagering and event-based prediction market trading, an approach IC360 believes will set the new industry standard as sportsbooks and prediction market exchanges increasingly operate side by side.

    • “DraftKings is built for entertainment, and we want sports fans to have fun and enjoy the games they love in a responsible way,” said Lori Kalani, Chief Responsible Gaming Officer at DraftKings. “There is no place for harassment of athletes or attempts to manipulate sports markets in our industry. Our work with IC360 gives us additional tools to identify and address this type of conduct and uphold the integrity of sports.”

  • Polymarket Launches Squads, Bringing the Group Chat to Prediction Markets (press release): Polymarket, the world’s largest prediction market, today announced the launch of Squads, a new social experience within the US Polymarket app that gives friends a dedicated place to talk markets, share their picks and trade together directly on Polymarket.

    • Squads brings the conversations already happening in group chats onto Polymarket, putting the conversation and the action in one place and making it easier for friends to experience the platform together.

    • “People are constantly debating what’s going to happen next with their friends and sharing predictions in group chats,” said Travis VanderZanden, Chief Growth Officer at Polymarket. “With Squads, we’re bringing the conversation and trading together so friends can follow the events they care about and make their predictions in one place. No better time to start than right before football season kicks off.”

  • Kalshi is doing “wrapped” style reels for users ahead of football season:

📖 Everything else you should know/read

  • My podcast has a YouTube channel now: Check it out here.

  • There are some words about prediction markets in here:

    • Citizens Analyst: Sports Betting Football Handle To Grow 5% This Year (InGame): “Prediction market cannibalization is ‘not getting worse, potentially is even easing,’ Bender wrote based on an analysis of customer wallets. Other insights include ‘evidence that wallets split between the PM and OSB are expanding’ and that competition for new customers as well as ‘self-inflicted wounds’ have been driving down online sports betting handle. Juice Reel shows that 4% of online sports betting handle has moved to prediction markets, and that there was a ‘notable slowdown’ in overall and per-user handle between December 2025-February 2026, when Kalshi first started offering sports event contracts.”

  • Kalshi, the US Open and betting: tennis’ biggest contradiction (Clay): “Players can’t do anything with a betting sponsorship, but tournaments benefit from it. We receive a lot of negativity from bettors. We get a lot of hate on social media, so it’s hard to see them as sponsors,” said world No. 3 Jessica Pegula."

  • Why Kalshi dropped generative AI in favor of human creativity (Ad Age, paywall): “Kalshi made one of the most attention-grabbing AI-generated ads of 2025. A year later, the prediction market is deliberately moving in the opposite direction.”